Tuesday, April 15, 2014

Tales From Old Ireland

Tales from Old Ireland was retold by Malachi Doyle and illustrated by Niamh Sharkey.  It was published in 2000 by Barefoot Books.

When looking for a collection of traditional tales, Tales from Old Ireland caught my eye because it is stories from Ireland  I have ancestors from Ireland and it is on my bucket list to visit Ireland, so I thought it would be interesting to read some traditional tales from my ancestors since I have never heard any from my family.

Doyle tells us in her introduction, "The Irish oral tradition is one of the richest in the world -- stories have been told around our firesides for thousands of years and tradition has never died.  Some of the myths and legends, folk and fairy tales told now are the same ones that were heard in the times of the early Celts, long before Christianity came to Ireland.  Others were written down by monks as early as the seventh century, but most were passed on solely by word of mouth.  In the nineteenth century, people began to collect and published the songs and stories that had survived, gathering them from the country people, mainly in the Irish language. When the Irish Folklore Commission was set up in the1930s, one of the ways it went about its job was to encourage schoolchildren to ask the oldest people in their area to tell them their stories.  The greatest collection of folklore in the word was thus assembled, and it is now held at University College, Dublin."

This book has a collection of seven stories -- (1) The Children of Lir, (2) Fair, Brown, and Trembling, (3) The Twelve Wild Geese, (4) Lusmore and the Fairies, (5) Son of an Otter, Son of a Wolf, (6) The Soul Cages, and (7) Oisin in Tir na nOg. 

The first two stories reminded me of Cinderella -- The Children of Lir because it has a jealous stepmother who hates her stepchildren.  There are four children; three boys and a girl, and their new step mother hates them from the second she sets her eyes on them. She tries to have someone kill them, but is refused, so instead she turns them into swans, cursing them with 900 years of confinement to the lakes.  They are able to speak and think, but cannot change back to their human form.  When their father finds out what his new wife has done, he curses her to be ugly for the rest of her life and visits his children at the lake as often as possible.  At the end of their 900 years, they are able to turn back into humans, "but they are 900 years old, so they die."  I didn't really get the message of this tale.  They never succeeded in trumping their stepmother or moving beyond their curse.

Fair, Brown and Trembling was more like Cinderella than The Children of Lir.  It was about three sisters -- the older two, Fair and Brown, are snobby and selfish, while the youngest, Trembling is caring and selfless.  Trembling cleans the house and makes all of the meals for her sisters and mother while the others demean her and take her for granted.  While the others go to church, Trembling has to stay home in her clothing of rags.  Her henwife came into the home and asked what Trembling would like to wear. When she described her perfect dress -- "a dress as white as the winter snow with emerald shoes for my feet" -- the henwife produces it and sent Trembling to church with the warning to not enter the church and not allow any of the men to catch up with her.  This was repeated three times, with three different outfits, until a man did catch up with her.  He knocked her shoe off and had to scour the town to find Trembling and marry her. 

Although the first two stories were my favorite, I did also like Lusmore and the Fairies.  This tale had an actual message, as it shows what happens to those who are kind versus those who are mean and rude.  Lusmore is a hunchbacked man who could hear the fairies singing -- "Monday, Tuesday, Monday Tuesday, Monday Tuesday, pause.  Monday, Tuesday,  Monday, Tuesday, Monday, Tuesday, pause." He  started to get annoyed with the fairies only singing the two days, so on their pause, he said, "Wednesday." The fairies were so grateful for his kind word and gentle demeanor that they brought him back to their home and magically took off his hump.  He was able to stand tall for the first time in his life.  When word got out, another man tried the same thing.  Now the fairies were singing "Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday" and the man gruffly yelled "Thursday Friday!"  They were so upset with him for the way he spoke to them that they took him back to their home and added another hump to his back.  I feel as thought this tale teaches others that tone is also important.  What you say is not always as important as how you say it and it can change what people think of you.

I had never heard versions of many of these tales.  I found several of them weird, as they had people mating with animals and fish being more wise than people.  If you would like to read all of the tales, you can find the book at Worldcat. 

Monday, April 14, 2014

The Secret Life of Bees

The Secret Life of Bees was written by Sue Monk Kidd.  It was published in 2002 by Penguin Books.


The Secret Life of Bees is a historical fiction book set in the time of the Civil Rights Movement.  It began soon after Lyndon Johnson signed the Civil Rights Act into law.  I feel as though it is a loosely defined historical fiction, as it was really a story of Lily and her anguish over her life circumstances. The only reason it would be classified as historical fiction is because of the time it is set in. There are events that happen that make the reader realize it is not current times, but more on that later.

The main character, Lily, is a young white girl living with her father, T. Ray.  We find out early in the book that her mother is dead, and it is hinted that Lily is the one who accidentally killed her mother with her father's gun when she was four years old. The only thing she had of her mother's was a picture of Black Mary with the words Tiburon, South Carolina written on the back.  Since that time, she has been raised by Rosaleen, a black peach picker on her father's peach farm.  T. Ray was around, but her was an awful father.  He made Lily kneel on grits when she misbehaved.  The grits tore her knees up to the point she could barely walk.  He also hit her and showed her very little love. On Lily's 14th birthday, everything changes.  Lily had always been captivated by bees. She caught some in her jar, and realized it had taken them all day to leave the jar when she let them go.  That's when she heard a voice. "Lily Melissa Owens, your jar is open.  In a matter of seconds I knew exactly what I had to do -- leave.  I had to get away from T. Ray, who was probably on his way back this minute to do Lord-knows-what to me.  Not to mention I had to get Roseleen out of jail."  You see -- Rosaleen had dumped her snuff on white men when they tormented her about wanting to register to vote.  After she was arrested, the same men went to the jail and beat her. The police took her to the hospital to get stitches.  Lily ran away, stopping at the hospital to help Rosaleen escape.  They went to the only place she knew may get her close to her mother -- Tiburon, South Carolina.

Once in Tiburon, Lily saw another picture of the Black Mary. It was the label for a jar of honey. She found that a woman named August made the honey and found her way to August's house.  She lied her way into staying there with August and her sister's, May and June (their mother loved spring and summer).  She knew her mother had once been at this house, but couldn't bring herself to tell them why she was there. She stayed for almost two months before finally coming clean.  She loved August and her sisters, as did Rosaleen. They had become family.  She also fell in love with August's worker, Zach. "The whole time we worked, I marveled at how mixed up people got when it came to love. I myself, for instance. It seemed like I was thinking of Zach forty minutes out of every hour, Zach, who was an impossibility."  He also knew they couldn't be together. "Lily, I like you better than any girl I've ever known, but you have to understand, there are people who would kill boys like me for even looking at girls like you." 

Once Lily felt close enough to August, she told her the truth of why she was there.  I will not ruin the book by spoiling everything that happened, but just say that Kidd did a magnificent job of showing how people love each other, family or not.

Like I stated earlier, this book was much more a story of Lily's coming of age than a story of the Civil Rights Movement, but it was such a great story of Lily's coming of age that I'm willing to excuse the fact that it is slightly deceiving as a historical fiction.  Kidd wrote the characters with many dimensions.  Augusts' sister, June, started off hating Lily.  She didn't want to allow her in to the house and tried to convince August to kick her out.  "You know she is lying.  She doesn't belong her." When August continues to allow Lily to stay, June responds with, "But she's white!" June was bitter towards white people, as she never thought it was right the way whites treated blacks and hated that August worked for a white family when she was younger.  By the end of the book, June and Lily were family.  During a religious ceremony, June tells Lily, "I'm sorry for the way I treated you when you first got here" and kisses the top of her head. 

Lily also changed a lot throughout the book.  She started off as a mousy girl who only worried about what others thought of her.  She wasn't well-liked at school, and always hoped to grow into someone beautiful.  She hadn't felt love for or by anyone since her mother had died.  By the end of the book, she was a hard-working, confident young lady who stood up to T.Ray and knew she had a family surrounding her.


If you would like to read more about The Secret Life of Bees, you can find more information and watch the movie trailer at its official website.  Once you are hooked and want to read the book, you can find a local copy at Worldcat.

Friday, April 11, 2014

Fever 1793

Fever 1793 was written by Laurie Anderson.  It was published by Aladdin Paperbacks in 2000.

Fever 1793 follows the story of young Mattie Cook and her friends and family during the yellow fever epidemic of 1793 in Philadelphia.  Mattie worked in her widowed mother's coffee shop with another young girl, Polly.  The day Polly didn't show up for work was when they realized something was wrong in the city.  Mattie's mother went to check on Polly to find out she had died.  This was in late August, 1793.  By October, thousands of people had died of yellow fever. 

Mattie's mother was the first of their family to get sick.  When she fell ill, she allowed their employee, Eliza, to stay with her, but sent Mattie and her father-in-law, away.  After leaving, Mattie also fell ill.  She was able to be nursed back to health, and by the time she made it back to Philadelphia, her mother was missing.  Mattie didn't know if her mother had died or if she had gone after Mattie.

Mattie and her grandfather moved back into the coffeehouse, where her grandfather was killed by intruders. Mattie then went to look for Eliza, finally finding someone she could stay with and help through the epidemic.  On her way to find Eliza, she met a young girl, Nell, who had just lost her mother.  She allowed Nell to join her and took care of her. She worked with Eliza for weeks, tending to those who fell ill from yellow fever.  The epidemic finally ended in late October, after the first frost came.  It was then that Mattie's mother came back.  They were reunited at the family coffeehouse and continued their lives in the wake of the epidemic. 

Laurie Anderson wove real people into her story. Mattie had a young suitor, Nathanial, who lived with and worked with the Peale family.  Although Nathanial was fictional, the Peales were a real family who endured the tragedy in 1793.  According to Anderson's notes, they were "the first family of American art."  Anderson also wrote about Dr. Rush and the French doctors and their argument over which treatment was better for yellow fever.  Dr. Rush believed in herbs, medicines and "bleeding" the sick, while the French doctors believed in fresh air, rest and fluids.  In Anderson's notes, she states that it is believed that Rush's medical practices most likely killed more people than he helped and it was the advice of the French that should have been taken. 

At the beginning of the book, Mattie was a bratty daughter.  "Children did what was asked of them. And mother n ever complained. Oh, no, never.  Good children were seen and not heard. How utterly unlike me."  Mattie always thought she was better than her plight in life.  She believed her mother was old-fashioned and didn't understand the grand ideas Mattie had -- wanting to go to France, adding on to the business, dating Nathanial, and they fought over her work ethic constantly.  Anderson showed great development in Mattie, as by the end of the book, she was a loving daughter, and quasi-mother (to Nell), a business owner and a grown child who could make her own decisions.

I feel as though this book is authentic to the time and Anderson did a very good job of incorporating true history into this story.  There was constant mentioning of Jefferson and Washington, as well as her use of real families and doctors.  She had pages of notes at the back of the book, explaining her research on the epidemic, the doctors, the Peales, food markets, famous people affected by the fever and reactions of those who were able to flee from Philadelphia. 

Watch the trailer below and find the book at Worldcat.

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

The War Within These Walls

The War Within These Walls was written by Aline Sax and illustrated by Caryl Strzelecki.  It was translated by Laura Watkinson. In  2011, it was published by Eerdans Books for Young Readers.


The War Within These Walls is one of the most captivating, yet sad stories I have ever read.  I read through it twice to ensure I got everything I could out of it, as the first time through I was in such shock and full of emotion. I've read the history on WWII and the years leading up to it, but I've never read something that made me feel so angry and so outraged for the people who suffered through it as The War Within These Walls did.

This award winning book (2014 Batchelder Honor book, 2013 National Jewish Book Award for Children and Young Adults) follows the story of Misha, a young boy who is forced into the Jewish ghetto with thousands of other people.  "Possessions, houses, women were requisitioned.  I had to wear an armband, too.  I was no longer allowed to go out with my friends. I was not permitted to sit with them on a bench or to play soccer in the park.  I had never felt so Jewish before." This quote reminded me of Max from The Book Thief when he stated that he was now German -- but he had always been German.

Sax's description and Strzelecki's illustrations depict the horror Misha and the others must endure daily.  When they first arrived in the Warsaw ghetto, there was food and jobs for most people.  As time went on and people from all over the country were also brought there, food ran out quickly.  With everyone just trying to survive, they would trade off their belongings for minuscule amounts of food.  Finally, there was just no food left. "It was astonishing how quickly you got used to the smell of starvation and the sight of naked corpses."  This is when Misha rebelled for the first time.  He found a way out of the ghetto, through the sewers.  He was able to make it to a bakery and would bring food back for his family nightly. That is, until, the German soldiers caught on.  They vowed to kill anyone they found smuggling food into the ghetto. "People who slipped through the gates were shot.  Children who crawled through holes in the walls were beaten to death. Every day more corpses dangled from the lampposts.  With signs around their necks. Schmuggler -- Smuggler." This quote made me feel so sad for humanity.  I cannot understand how anyone would not just stand around and watch them be tortured by hunger, but kill them for trying to survive that hunger.  It was after this that Misha no longer had the courage to get more food. 

After another year, the people of the Warsaw ghetto had another fear. The signs explaining that they are to be resettled began to show up.  Misha's family was able to stay because his father was a doctor at the hospital and part of the Jewish Council.  This was when Misha realized something even worse happened when you left.  He saw thousands of people leaving, and none of them ever returned.  He heard the rumors of the death camps and couldn't believe resettlement was a positive thing, as many of the other people did.

It was in this time that he met Mordechai Anielewicz. Anielewicz was a real man and according to the notes Sax wrote at the end of the book, "Anielewicz was only 23 years old when he took command of Jewish resistance forces in the Warsaw ghetto.  Under his leadership, fighters made their first stand against the Nazis in January, 1943."  Aneilewicz had lead Misha and hundreds of others in their rebellion.  He knew they would most likely not make it out, but felt as though they should as least die an honorable death.  They fought for over a month, but in the end, the ghetto was destroyed.  Almost everyone in it had been killed. In The War Within These Walls, only Misha and one other woman survived.  They escaped the ghetto to tell the story of the cruelty to the word.

Sax's honest description of the horrific deeds done by the German Nazis made this book what it was.  There was scene after scene that made me tear up, but the most memorable for me was the following:

"A German soldier raced back into my field of vision. He gestured at the woman.  Her eyes staring down at her feet, she handed him a piece of paper. The soldier didn't read it.  He threw it on the ground and spat on it.  The woman kneeled, but didn't dare to pick up the paper. Then everything happened so quickly.  The soldier kicked over the baby carriage. A bundle of blankets fell onto the ground and started to wail.  The woman reached for the baby. The soldier grabbed the child by one leg. The child shrieked. The mother screamed. The soldier slammed the child against the wall. I closed my eyes. But I couldn't close my ears. The woman's scream was stopped by a shot.  Somewhere in the distance I heard a truck start up again and drive on."

As in all good historical fiction, this book makes you feel for the human element. It goes beyond the facts of the time and pulls at your heart and makes you angry.  This book would hook students learning about WWII.  It would make them want to learn more about what happened and why. How could it not? It is from the view of a teenage boy. A teenage boy that could have been any one of them, had they been born in a different time. 

You can find additional information on the Warsaw ghetto uprising by visiting the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum.


To watch the trailer for this book, click here.

Monday, April 7, 2014

elsewhere

elsewhere is a young adult book written by Gabrielle Zevin. It was published by Squarefish in 2005.

A couple of days after finishing The Giver, I was perusing the library to find the next book I wanted to read.  I was looking through the fantasy section, hoping something would pop out at me.  When I saw the book elsewhere, I knew this was the next read for me.  I found it interesting that its title word was so often mentioned in The Giver, and it is for that reason that I chose this book to read.

elsewhere is about the journey Elizabeth (Liz) Hall had after she was hit by a taxi when crossing the street.  It is split into five parts:
                 Prologue: In the End,
                 Part I: The Nile
                 Part II: The Book of the Dead
                 Part III: Antique Lands
                 Epilogue: In the Beginning

The prologue is narrated by Liz's dog, Lucy. Through Lucy's ramblings, we can determine that Liz has died and her family, including her younger brother Alvy, as well as Lucy, is missing her terribly.  Lucy was Liz's dog, and has not been taken very good care of since Liz's passing.  "The next day the mother takes Lucy to the dog park.  It's the first time anyone has remembered to walk Lucy since the end." While reading the prologue, my initial thought was, "Oh, goodness, not another book from an animal's perspective." Luckily for me, the rest of the book was in third person narration, which I thought was a better choice for this story. 

Liz 'wakes up' on a boat, on her way to Elsewhere.  She doesn't realize what has happened to her yet and feels as though she is in a dream. She has a roommate, Thandi, and they explore the ship together.  While at breakfast, they also find a former rock star, Curtis Jest.  Thandi has a bullet hole in her head and Curtis' arm was deteriorating from the drugs he had taken while alive.  Both of them had now figured out they were dead, but Liz still believed it was a dream.  She started to remember what had happened to her -- being hit by a taxi cab while she rode her bike across the street to the mall -- but assumed it was all part of her dream.  She didn't take it well when she figured out she was dead.  "Suddenly, Liz needs to sit down.  She is cold and breathless.  'Thandi, I need to know how you got the hole in your head.'"  After Thandi explained her situation, Liz goes on, "Are you sure you aren't dreaming all of this? I'm sorry, I"m just trying to figure everything out." Thandi lets out a long, plaintive sigh, 'Girl, you are in denial,' she said."

Once Liz realizes she is dead, she tries to figure out a way to go back to earth.  She is not successful, and must move on to Elsewhere, where she is met by her grandmother, Betty, who had died when Liz was not yet born.  This is when Liz, and the readers, realize the afterlife is not exactly what was expected. In Elsewhere, death is very similar to life.  You can drive, swim, eat, drink, sleep and even fall in love.  What makes it different is you cannot get mortally hurt and you age backwards. Whatever age you enter Elsewhere is the number of years you will live there.  As time goes on, you get younger, until you are again a baby and are 'released' back to earth for another life (again -- a connection to The Giver.  How ironic that in The Giver, release is death, while in elsewhere, it is life.)

When Liz arrives at Elsewhere, she is incredibly depressed and only wants to watch her family and friends from the Observation Deck.  She is able to watch them in 5 minute increments, and this is all she does for the first month of her death.  She also learns that there is a 'well' at the bottom of the ocean, where one could try to make contact with the living.  She desperately wants her father to know that she had a hidden birthday present for him, so she dove down to the well to reach him.  She was able to reach her brother, but he didn't quite understand her message.  Before she could try again, she was caught by the Elsewhere Police Detective, Owen Welles. 

Owen is the person who helps Liz get through her depression and move on in death. He convinced her to take a job, learn to drive and enjoy the time they had together.  Eventually, they fall in love.  Although they are aging backwards, they spend all of their time together, until Liz's fifteen years in Elsewhere were up, and she was 'released' back to earth for another go-around.

There is much more I could write in the summary, but wanted to only hit the most important parts.  What I find most important is that this class has changed my perception when reading.  Pre-Diversity in Children's Literature Rebecca would have enjoyed reading this book.  She would have thought it was a cute idea for a story and the setting or storyline wouldn't have bothered her at all.  Post-Diversity in Children's Literature Rebecca is annoyed with this book, or at least, how some of the book was written.  I did not find it to be believable and found some of the rules of Elsewhere didn't make sense.  Elsewhere was just like life, only after death.  It didn't make sense to me that the people still ate and breathed and had beating hearts.  They're dead.  Another question that arose as I was reading was about the Observation Deck. People had to buy time to watch their family, but they could buy 5 minutes or 500 minutes, and it was the same price. That just didn't make sense to me.  Why would anyone buy 5 minutes when they could get any number of minutes for the same price?  Another idea I couldn't buy was the idea of them falling in love.  After Liz and Owen fell in love, Owen's wife from earth died and came to Elsewhere.  He left Liz and allowed his wife to move in with him, only to later realize that their new age difference (he had died at 26, and been dead 10 years, so with her aging normally, she was now 36, and with him aging backwards, he was 16) made things very hard for them and they were two different people than who they were when he died. He got back with Liz, and as he continued to grow younger, his once wife not treated him like she was his babysitter. The whole idea was just unsettling to me.

What I did find interesting is that the author doesn't care about the after-life.  At the end of the book, it gives responses to questions she was asked. One question was "What would your readers be most surprised to learn about you?" Her answer was, "Assuming they'd read elsewhere, they'd probably be surprised to know how much I don't care about the after-life. The way I really feel about it is 'que sera, sera.'"  That was surprising since many authors write about things that are personal to them or they have an interest in.

elsewhere has many mixed reviews.  If you would like to read what others thought about it before deciding whether to read it or not, you can go to Goodreads.  If you think you'll enjoy it, you can find a copy of the book at WorldCat. 

Sunday, April 6, 2014

Charlotte's Web

Charlotte's Web was written by E.B. White and illustrated by Garth Williams.  It was published in 1952 by Harper and Row.

I chose to read Charlotte's Web, a Newberry Honor book, because it has been over twenty years since the last time I read it.  I remember it fondly as a child and wanted to revisit and old favorite to see if I continued to enjoy it as an adult.

Charlotte's Web tale of Wilbur, the pig, and his best friend, Charlotte, a spider. Wilbur was the runt of his litter and his owner, Mr. Arable, wanted to kill him.  He said "the runt is more trouble than it's worth" and tried to take an ax to Wilbur.  Mr. Arable's daughter, Fern, saved Wilbur and raised him as her infant until he could live on his own, at which time Mr. A sold Wilbur to his neighbor and brother-in-law Homer Zuckerman. There were several other animals at the farm for Wilbur to talk to -- a goose and gander, a sheep, cows, and a rat, Templeton. None of the animals considered Wilbur to be his friend, so he was very excited when he met a new animal -- Charlotte. Wilbur's life was going okay (he didn't love that he had to stay fenced in or the love he now missed from Fern) until the other animals explained to him that he was being fattened up for the Zuckerman's Christmas pig.  Once he knew that, he was scared and worried all of the time.  Charlotte promised to save him, and came up with an idea to help.  Charlotte was quite the clever spider and she didn't feel as though humans were all that bright. "'The way to save Wilbur's life is to play a trick on Zuckerman. If I can fool a bug,' thought Charlotte, 'I can surely fool a man. People are not as smart as bugs.'" Charlotte's idea -- to create webs with words describing Wilbur -- worked. The Arables and the Zuckerman's were astonished, as were the many visitors their farm received.  The Zuckerman's even won an award for Wilbur at the state fair because of how intrigued everyone was with Wilbur.  True to her promise, Charlotte saved Wilbur, but all did not turn out well for everyone.  At the state fair, Charlotte died.  She knew she was going to, and was able to lay her egg sac beforehand.  Wilbur took the egg sac home and lived with her children and grandchildren for the rest of his years.

This story is one of great friendship and compassion.  Charlotte stepped up to be Wilbur's friend when no other animal wanted anything to do with him. She was kind to him from the beginning. "'Salutations are greetings,' said the voice. 'When I say salutations, it's just my fancy way of saying hello or good morning.  Actually, it's a silly expression, and I am surprised that I said it at all. As for my whereabouts, that's easy.  Look up here in the corner of the doorway! here I am. Look, I'm waving!"' From that moment on, she was Wilbur's best friend.  Wilbur was quite naive and took Charlotte's friendship for granted.  He got frustrated with her when she didn't come up with a way to save him right away, and became angry when she wasn't sure if she would be joining him at the fair. Although she told him she wasn't feeling that well and didn't plan on going, he begged her. "'Please come with me,' begged Wilbur. I need you, Charlotte! I can't stand to go to the fair without you. You've just got to come!'"  When Charlotte finally agreed, Wilbur forgot completely of her not feeling well and only responded, "Oh good!  I knew you wouldn't forsake me just when I needed you most."

Because of the way Wilbur reacted to Charlotte, for much of the book, I considered their friendship one sided.  It wasn't until the end when Wilbur took Charlotte's egg sac that I saw him truly return the friendship. He was kind to all of her offspring, for generations to come. 

It was interesting to read a book that had been published over 60 years ago.  The culture of how they grew up and were portrayed so much differently than today. On page 4, White writes, "Avery was ten.  He was heavily armed -- an air rifle in one hand, a wooden dagger in the other." Knowing that today, a student gets expelled for having a play gun on his key chain, it amazes me that there was a time kids could get on the bus with air rifles and wooden daggers.  It was also a shock when the Arables allowed Fern and Avery to run off on their own at the fair.  Maybe I'm a little overprotective of my own children, but I couldn't imagine allowing them to go off on their own in such a public place.

Overall, Charlotte's Web was just as good of a book today as it was when I was a child.  The friendship between Fern and Wilbur, and then Wilbur and Charlotte, was heartwarming.  They each grew and moved on in their own way.  Fern started growing up and enjoying time with Henry, instead of coming to the farm.  The Zuckerman's kept Wilbur safe from the Christmas dinner and allowed him to live his life on the farm.  Even Wilbur grew in his understanding of friendship after Charlotte passed away.  He wanted to ensure a good life for her babies, and did just that, for generations of spiders.  Charlotte's Web is a wonderful book for children. If you would like to find a copy, you can find it here.






Tuesday, April 1, 2014

The Watson's Go to Birmingha -- 1963


The Watsons go to Birmingham – 1963 was written by Christopher Paul Curtis.  It was published by Yearling in 1995.

The Newberry Honor book, The Watson’s go to Birmingham – 1963, is a historical fiction book about a black family and their world in 1963.  The narrator of the story is Kenny, the middle child in this 5 person family.  He has one older brother, Byron (By) and a younger sister, Joetta (Joey) and live in Flint, Michigan with their parents. 

I feel as though this is a pretty typical family. They ‘cut up’ with each other (a term I had thought was pretty recent until I read this book!), picked on each other, and stuck up for each other to people outside of the family.  They joke around often, yet the kids know when the parents are being serious and know when to shut it down. The hierarchy is similar to many families in real life.  The oldest brother, By, tortures Kenny in his sibling rivalry, although he keeps others from making fun of him, as he is an easy target with his bright mind and lazy eye.  Kenny holds his own with By through most of the book, and you can tell that they really do love each other.  The youngest sibling, Joey, is a typical youngest child.  She looks out for her brothers and doesn’t want them to get in trouble by their parents, and if often the one pleading for leniency with it comes to By.  In one scene, after By has again been caught playing with matches, his mother is ready to teach him a lesson by burning him.  She feels as though it is worth burning him if he learns that he cannot play with matches that might someday burn down the house and kill the family.  Joetta tries to stop mom from going ‘crazy’ with By. 

                “Momma’s voice got strange, hissing like a snake.  ‘Joetta, go out to the kitchen and bring me a                book of matches.’ 

                ‘But Mommy…,’ Joey said, starting to get all sobby.

                ‘Joetta, do what I told you.’

                ‘Mommy, I can’t…’ The tears really started coming and Joey was squeezing my arm.

                ‘Joetta, go get those matches!

                ‘Please, Mommy, he won’t  do it again, will you Byron? Promise her, promise Mommy you won’t             do it again!”

Later, after Mom gets the matches herself, Joey continues to help her brother by blowing out the match each time her mother got too close to By.  This is just one example of the way Joey stands up to try to defend and help her brothers throughout the book.  This is also an example of extreme discipline throughout the book.  I do feel as though this family is a very good family and the parents care a lot about each other and their kids, but they are not parents to be messed with.  The children have consequences -- sometimes severe consequences -- for their behavior.  Most of the consequences wouldn't be seen as good parenting today, as their were several beatings throughout the book, but I tried to keep in mind that this was a different era with a different culture of people. 
                Although the title alludes to the family being in Birmingham, most of the book takes place in Flint, Michigan, where the family appears to be a pretty well-off family.  Kenny has a friend, Rufus, who cannot afford to bring lunch to school, so after Kenny’s mother realized this, she started sending four peanut butter sandwiches (two for Kenny, one for Rufus and one for Rufus’ younger brother) and three apples (one for each of them) for lunch every day.  They are also able to afford buying new gadgets and upgrades for their car, such a record player (who knew those were in cars?!) while they are getting ready for their trip to Birmingham.  The parents are from a generation of people who do not live on credit cards, and they appear to be smart and responsible with their money, planning their trip to the dime.  Although they are a responsible and loving family, Byron has been getting in a lot of trouble.  He “is officially a teenage juvenile” often making poor decisions such as skipping school, fighting other kids, and playing with matches.  He refuses to listen to his parents, so he is being sent south to live with his grandmother for the summer.  If he can’t shape up, he’ll be there longer.

                Throughout most of the book, it could have been realistic fiction.  It wasn’t until the last third of the book that they went to Birmingham, which is what allowed for it to be considered historical fiction. The time Watsons was set in was during the Civil Rights Era.  Mr. and Mrs. Watson tried to explain to their children that the south was much different than the north at that time (as it still is, in many ways).  They tried to warn them that black people were not as accepted in the south as they are in the north, but the kids didn’t really understand until tragedy struck while they were in Birmingham.  Without giving away what happens, the family had to suffer and event that far too many real-life people had to suffer through during that time.  They saw first-hand the destruction racism and hatred could have, without much consequence to the destructors.

                I really enjoyed this book. It was a fun, easy read, with characters that are relatable to anyone who reads it.  The children are funny and real, cutting it up with the best of them.  The parents are genuine and believe in taking care of the children – not letting the streets raise them.  They expect the children to be responsible, educated children, who are kind and generous to others. 


                Watsons is part of the fourth grade curriculum in Newport News and it is a book I would love to work through with my fourth grade students.  I am looking forward to helping my students understand what has happened in our country and teach them about what many of their grandparents or great parents had to go through during the Civil Rights Era.  If you would also like to study this book with your students, you can find local copies here.  The Watson’s Go To Birmingham – 1963 has been turned into a movie on the Hallmark channel.  It goes much further into the fight for Civil Rights and the Watson’s realize how different the south is in the movie. You can find the trailer, with more information here.